Why doesn't my bank finance co-ops?

Keith Gumbinger

Q: Why doesn't my bank finance co-ops?

A: Some banks shy away from lending for cooperative apartments. There are likely several reasons for this, but perhaps most important is that these aren't mortgages made against real estate (which is considered "real" property) but rather loans made to buy shares of stock in a corporation (which is what a co-op purchase is considered).

The risks of these loans are different that those found on traditional mortgages, since any foreclosure process would leave a lender not with real property to dispose of, but rather shares of stock -- literally, pieces of paper. Co-op loans require (very) different kinds of contracts, as there are risks with regard to financial health of the corporation that owns the building (plus the condition and maintenance of the building itself), and plenty of other legal aspects that make offering and funding these loans different from traditional mortgage lending.

Unlike regular mortgages, most lenders don't make enough of these to be able to profitably sell them to other investors or in the secondary markets, so they often end up in a bank's portfolio. While Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will purchase so-called "cooperative share loans", they don't do so in all states, and a patchwork of state laws regarding co-ops also complicates matters for lenders and investors. In addition, Fannie's website notes that "a lender must be specially approved to sell cooperative (or "co-op") share loans to Fannie Mae."

Most banks don't prefer to hold fixed-rate mortgages in portfolio, so you may find that in cases where a lender does make co-op loans they may only offer ARMs, not fixed rates. With all these additional concerns, obligations and low origination volumes, some lenders just can't be bothered to make them at all, concentrating instead on bigger portions of the residential market.

Ask the expert
Keith Gumbinger
Keith Gumbinger
Mortgage Expert
Vice President, HSH.com
About Keith: Mortgage market observer and analyst with 35 years experience... (more)
Please enter a question.
Please enter name.
Please enter email.
Captcha code invalid
Q: Does mortgage insurance assist the survivors of a deceased policy holder?
APR 08, 2025
A:

Credit life insurance is sold to homeowners as a means to pay off the mortgage in the event of the death of the homeowner.

Read More
Q: I don't have a Social Security number. Can I get a mortgage?
MAR 31, 2025
A:

Fannie Mae states they do back loans for borrowers who have no Social Security number.

Read More
Q: Will I pay an ACA/ObamaCare tax when I sell my home?
JAN 17, 2025
A:

Some homeowners will pay this 3.8 percent tax when they sell their homes, but only if they meet certain conditions.

Read More
Add to Homescreen?
X
X
Install this web app on your phone :tap and then Add to homescreen